Understanding Hypertonic vs. Hypotonic Pelvic Floor
When most women think about pelvic floor problems, they assume their muscles are too weak. But here is something that might surprise you: a significant number of women actually have a pelvic floor that is too tight, not too weak. This condition is called hypertonicity, and treating it the same way you would treat weakness can make things much worse.
The pelvic floor is a group of muscles that must be able to both contract and relax to function properly. Think of it like your bicep: if you held your arm in a flexed position all day, the muscle would become short, fatigued, and paradoxically weak. The same thing happens with your pelvic floor.
Key insight: A pelvic floor that is too tight (hypertonic) can produce many of the same symptoms as one that is too weak (hypotonic) — including leakage. This is why getting the right assessment is critical before starting any exercise program.
Symptoms of a Hypertonic (Too Tight) Pelvic Floor
A hypertonic pelvic floor occurs when the muscles are chronically contracted or in spasm. Women with this condition often experience:
- Pain during intimacy — often described as a burning or sharp sensation
- Difficulty fully emptying the bladder — feeling like you always need to go
- Chronic constipation — the tight muscles restrict normal bowel function
- Pelvic pain or pressure — a persistent ache in the pelvis, hips, or lower back
- Urinary urgency or frequency — needing to urinate very often
- Tailbone pain (coccydynia) — especially when sitting for prolonged periods
Important Warning
If you have a hypertonic pelvic floor, doing traditional Kegels or strengthening exercises can worsen your symptoms. Tightening an already-tight muscle leads to more pain, more spasm, and more dysfunction. Always get assessed before beginning a pelvic floor program.
Symptoms of a Hypotonic (Too Weak) Pelvic Floor
A hypotonic pelvic floor is what most women picture when they think of pelvic floor dysfunction. The muscles lack the strength and endurance to adequately support the pelvic organs. Common symptoms include:
- Stress urinary incontinence — leaking when you cough, sneeze, laugh, or jump
- A feeling of heaviness or "falling out" — the sensation that something is dropping in the pelvis
- Difficulty holding a contraction — you cannot squeeze and hold the muscles for more than a second or two
- Reduced sensation during intimacy
- Lower back pain that does not respond to standard treatments
Self-Assessment: Which Type Do You Have?
While a definitive diagnosis requires a pelvic floor physical therapist, there are some clues that can help you start to understand what is going on with your body:
Self-Assessment Questions
- Do you experience pain with pelvic floor contraction or during intimacy? This may point toward hypertonicity.
- Do you leak urine primarily with physical exertion but have no pelvic pain? This may point toward hypotonicity.
- Can you fully relax your pelvic floor after a contraction, or does it feel like the muscles stay "on"? Difficulty relaxing suggests tightness.
- Do you have a history of chronic stress, anxiety, or holding tension in your body? These are risk factors for a hypertonic pelvic floor.
- Have you had vaginal deliveries or significant hormonal changes? These are risk factors for a hypotonic pelvic floor.
Why Treatment Differs
This distinction matters because the treatment approach is fundamentally different. For a hypotonic pelvic floor, the focus is on strengthening: Kegels, core activation, glute work, and progressive resistance. For a hypertonic pelvic floor, the focus is on relaxation first: diaphragmatic breathing, gentle stretching, manual release techniques, and learning to "let go" of the muscles before any strengthening begins.
Many women spend months or even years doing the wrong exercises because they never received a proper assessment. If your symptoms have not improved with Kegels, it may be because your pelvic floor needs a different approach entirely.
Get the Complete Exercise Class
Follow along with the full 1+ hour video class
What to Do Next
The single best step you can take is to see a pelvic floor physical therapist who can perform an internal assessment and tell you exactly what is happening with your muscles. From there, you can follow a targeted program that addresses your specific needs — whether that is strengthening, relaxation, or a combination of both.
In the video above, I walk you through more details on recognizing these patterns in your own body and share guidance on the exercises that are appropriate for each type. Understanding whether your pelvic floor is too tight or too weak is the foundation of effective treatment.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if my pelvic floor is too tight or too weak?
A tight (hypertonic) pelvic floor often presents with pain during intimacy, difficulty emptying the bladder fully, constipation, and pelvic pain. A weak (hypotonic) pelvic floor typically causes urinary leakage, a feeling of heaviness or prolapse, and difficulty holding contractions. A pelvic floor physical therapist can provide a definitive assessment.
Can your pelvic floor be both tight and weak at the same time?
Yes, this is actually very common. A muscle that is chronically tight can also be weak because it is held in a shortened position and cannot generate force through a full range of motion. This is why a thorough assessment is important before starting exercises.
Should I do Kegels if my pelvic floor is too tight?
No. If your pelvic floor is hypertonic (too tight), doing Kegels can actually make your symptoms worse. The priority for a tight pelvic floor is learning to relax and lengthen the muscles first through breathing, stretching, and release techniques before any strengthening work.
What causes a hypertonic pelvic floor?
Common causes include chronic stress and tension holding, high-impact exercise without proper recovery, trauma or surgery in the pelvic area, habitual postures like clenching, anxiety, and conditions like endometriosis or interstitial cystitis. Sometimes there is no single identifiable cause.
How long does it take to fix a pelvic floor that is too tight or too weak?
Recovery timelines vary depending on severity and consistency with treatment. Most women notice initial improvements within 4-6 weeks of targeted exercises. Significant progress typically takes 3-6 months. A hypertonic pelvic floor may take longer because you need to learn relaxation before adding strengthening.
Sheree DiBiase
Sheree DiBiase has been a physical therapist for over 40 years, specializing in pelvic floor rehabilitation. She is the founder of Lake City Physical Therapy and the creator of the Pelvic Floor Pro app. Sheree is a board-certified Pelvic Rehabilitation Practitioner (PRPC) and has helped thousands of women regain pelvic floor strength and confidence.